Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 8 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Critique Rubric (1)
Critique Rubric (1)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Describe
threshold: pts
4 pts
The artwork, artist, date and media are identified; the vocabulary of the structures (elements) of art effectively and clearly describe the subject matter of the artwork
3.2 pts
The artwork and artist are identified, but the use of the vocabulary of the structures (elements) of art ineffectively describe the artwork
2.4 pts
A key piece of information is missing
0 pts
The description is missing
pts
4 pts
--
Analyze
threshold: pts
4 pts
Student uses art vocabulary to describe a minimum of 5 examples of the use of elements of art and principles of design within the artwork
3.2 pts
Less than 5 examples were described regarding the use of the elements and principles, but the examples were explained clearly using effective vocabulary.
2.4 pts
Less than 5 examples were described and the examples given are unclear.
0 pts
There are no examples given regarding the use of elements of art or principles of design
pts
4 pts
--
Interpret
threshold: pts
4 pts
Meaning of the artwork or intent of the artist is clearly discussed; multiple strong points of visual evidence found within the artwork support the interpretation
3.2 pts
Meaning of the artwork or intent of the artist is implied; limited or questionable visual evidence found within the artwork support the interpretation
2.4 pts
Meaning of the artwork or intent of the artist is not clearly discussed; faulty visual evidence visual evidence or no visual evidence cited to support the interpretation
0 pts
Interpretation is missing
pts
4 pts
--
Evaluation
threshold: pts
4 pts
The effectiveness of the artwork is evaluated; two or more pieces of evidence about the effectiveness are cited; judgment is based on evidence rather than opinion of like or dislike
3.2 pts
The effectiveness of the artwork is evaluated; one piece of evidence about the effectiveness is cited; judgment is based on evidence rather than opinion of like or dislike
2.4 pts
Evaluation suggests opinion rather than being based upon evidence
0 pts
Evaluation is missing
pts
4 pts
--
Grammar
threshold: pts
4 pts
No grammatical or spelling errors; highly polished and professional; philosophy could be published
3.2 pts
5 or less grammatical or spelling errors. Only slight revision necessary.
2.4 pts
Multiple errors; requires considerable revision
pts
4 pts
--
Total Points: 20 out of 20